Map Rotation Megathread

[DelabLeFou]

I've yet to play on half of the new maps, saturday didn't have them, my overall thoughts so far:

Silvertrail is really bad, not even the fun kind of bad, was obviously meant to be an experiment from the creator
Mach gets really boring after like 5 minutes, we already have vikings, barn and convoy for meme ctf map, we didn't need a fourth one imo
Panic is probably the best custom PLR map we've tried but it's still not very good, it's a C tier at best and I'd keep it for weekends if not outright remove
Redbounty is one I suggested, it's pretty mid, I was hoping cp_ferrum would get added and for redbounty to be considered, not the opposite
Airfield is great, no complain there

Replace silvertrail with method, mach with quarry (taking Carl's words for it)

Finally got to play on most of the new maps, and I'm mostly disappointed

Wildcat is a bit too confusing, not terrible but could be better

Basalt, I didn't like, I know a lot of people did but I found it awkward to play on

Hills, it's fine, but there's a lot of better koth maps

Munitions, was looking forward to trying it, ended up being very disappointed, underbaked and unfinished, rooms are too big and too empty. A shame that Rumford hasn't made it in but this has.

System, can't do much on it beside camp on your base or go on the enemy base, get 1 kill then die, the cart gimmick is fine

Oldwood, decent, probably the best CTF map we got, but not that amazing either

I still haven't tried priderock or radiant, the former is probably shit while the second is probably a meme map akin to barn and vikings

[Kvasorob]

I've yet to play on half of the new maps, saturday didn't have them, my overall thoughts so far:

Silvertrail is really bad, not even the fun kind of bad, was obviously meant to be an experiment from the creator
Mach gets really boring after like 5 minutes, we already have vikings, barn and convoy for meme ctf map, we didn't need a fourth one imo
Panic is probably the best custom PLR map we've tried but it's still not very good, it's a C tier at best and I'd keep it for weekends if not outright remove
Redbounty is one I suggested, it's pretty mid, I was hoping cp_ferrum would get added and for redbounty to be considered, not the opposite
Airfield is great, no complain there

Replace silvertrail with method, mach with quarry (taking Carl's words for it)

Finally got to play on most of the new maps, and I'm mostly disappointed

Wildcat is a bit too confusing, not terrible but could be better

Basalt, I didn't like, I know a lot of people did but I found it awkward to play on

Hills, it's fine, but there's a lot of better koth maps

Munitions, was looking forward to trying it, ended up being very disappointed, underbaked and unfinished, rooms are too big and too empty. A shame that Rumford hasn't made it in but this has.

System, can't do much on it beside camp on your base or go on the enemy base, get 1 kill then die, the cart gimmick is fine

Oldwood, decent, probably the best CTF map we got, but not that amazing either

I still haven't tried priderock or radiant, the former is probably shit while the second is probably a meme map akin to barn and vikings

radiant might be the best out of the bunch and it's an actual map and it's robot destruction, but it's layout is kinda mazey and gimmicky, and yeah it still doesn't play that well, try it when you'll be able to.

But yeah I agree with the rest, most maps are underwhelming and I may as well wouldn't even play them at all, though generally I don't like majority of custom maps castaway has except skyscraper and garbage day and maybe couple more I can't rememeber. And I feel like a lot of people share this attitude because I also basically never see a custom map like vikings when I play, thankfully, though I also play EU most of time. default map pool just has enough of solid maps to fuel an entire sesh for a day, and to play the next day and restart the previous day's maps and play them again. I am all for trying out new stuff and it's hard to rival original maps obviously, but majority of custom maps we have right now just dont feel any interesting to me and in fact I want to play the server less if it's on some obscure or boundary.

Maybe in future my opinions might change but for now I never feel like weekends are any different from weekdays, most people vote/nominate vanilla maps anyway and I can't try most new maps for a month now at this point, but every time I tried a new map I only knew disappointment, still haven't played priderock and I already heard that it's not that great. Only exception to all of this is oldwood, it's a pretty decent dm map, also reminds me a lot of dod_colmar because of visuals

[Asmo]

This is a pretty cool map, really nails the early TF2 aesthetic. You should add it in the next batch of custom maps.

CTF Vault

[random]

I'd like to set up a poll for maps in the next few days. This is going to be a rather large and sweeping poll because we have so many maps now. I want to have a poll for some of the lesser played official maps to be moved to the weekend rotation, for example haarp. This might also mean other official maps could return weekend-only, like watergate. This one will take a long time to set up due to the sheer number of maps so I'll do it when I get time

[PepsiMax [SAC]]

I think it's high time we did some culling to the map pool. Right now there's 96 maps in regular rotation. 125 on the weekends.

[skosgo]

Warpath is a really old map that I genuinely think the server would have a lot of fun playing especially with the weapon reverts.

[DelabLeFou]

Warpath is a really old map that I genuinely think the server would have a lot of fun playing especially with the weapon reverts.

This looks like it was made in 2 hours, stop suggesting maps just because it's le heckin old nostalgiarino, look at the last time we got a bunch of custom maps, 80% of them turned out to be bad

[Asmo]

I've got some map suggestions for the up and coming New Delhi server. I also elect Delab as the admin of this region.

Payload Toilet Water

Attack/Defend Toilet Bowl

Payload Upward Pro

Payload Poodoo

Payload Poo Rush

[DelabLeFou]

I've got some map suggestions for the up and coming New Delhi server. I also elect Delab as the admin of this region.

Payload Toilet Water

Attack/Defend Toilet Bowl

Payload Upward Pro

Payload Poodoo

Payload Poo Rush

Blud is making indian delab jokes in the big 26

[cyber]

Please add CTF Facing Worlds 2011

https://gamebanana.com/mods/70710

[Suspicious Carl]

a new robot destruction map just got posted to the workshop, that shits ultra rare we need to try this out and see if its good
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/ ... 3698548391
the other one seemed polarizing lets give this a go
EDIT: also a special delivery map, we love doomsday and asteroid fog we GOTTA try these
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/ ... 3696631536

[Scout]

a new robot destruction map just got posted to the workshop, that shits ultra rare we need to try this out and see if its good
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/ ... 3698548391
the other one seemed polarizing lets give this a go
EDIT: also a special delivery map, we love doomsday and asteroid fog we GOTTA try these
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/ ... 3696631536

I second these, from running around them in-game the SD map is my favorite of the two but the RD map is probably good as well

[Asmo]

a new robot destruction map just got posted to the workshop, that shits ultra rare we need to try this out and see if its good
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/ ... 3698548391
the other one seemed polarizing lets give this a go
EDIT: also a special delivery map, we love doomsday and asteroid fog we GOTTA try these
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/ ... 3696631536

I saw those on the workshop last week. I walked around both on a LAN server and Uplink seemed mediocre, but maybe it plays well. Eschaton looked very promising, would love to try it on a full server.